Wings of Starlight by Allison Saft | Book Review

Wings of Starlight by Allison Saft
Genre: Fantasy, Romance, Young Adult, Retelling
Pages: 400
Published By: Studio Press on 13th February, 2025
Format: Paperback and Audiobook
Source: Gifted (Instagram)
Add to Goodreads
Buy on Amazon (not affiliated)

Book Synopsis:

Book Review

I didn’t really grow up watching and obsessing over the Tinkerbell films but I have an appreciation for them due to being a Disney lover. I was excited to see this book release but didn’t rush to pick it up. However, one of my followers on Instagram kindly gifted it to me, and we decided to buddy read it together.

This book targets young adult readers, but it felt more middle grade due to its simple plot and underdeveloped characters. While still a fun read, it’s important to note that it doesn’t quite feel like YA.

The writing and descriptions of the setting were beautiful but again it felt childlike and came across like reading a Disney animated film. That is not necessarily a bad thing but just something I wanted to note in my review.

I started reading the book physically but found the story to be dragging at times… This is where I switched to listening to an audiobook on YouTube (couldn’t get it on Audible for some reason). The audiobook wasn’t narrated the best, but it helped me feel more immersed in the story than when I read it physically.

In terms of the romance, there was not enough depth and complexity to it… It felt like the author was reaching for something that could’ve been great but not quite hitting the mark. Again, it felt very childlike. Considering its promoted as YA, I expected more in terms of the romance. It felt like I was reading someone’s first crush – cute, simple and awkward.

I finished the book feeling like I expected more. The only word I can describe this story as mentioned in the previous paragraph is ‘cute’. However, for a supposedly YA book, you don’t want to leave the book thinking it was cute… It was an enjoyable but average read. I believe it should have been marketed as middle grade, not YA. Maybe I wouldn’t have had such high expectations if it had been. I gave it a .5 bump in the rating because it’s a book with FAIRIES, like come on.. FAIRIES! <3

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Discover more from Just Read Jessie

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

2 responses to “Wings of Starlight by Allison Saft | Book Review”

  1. Rosie Amber avatar

    Good review. A shame that the book didn’t hit the mark for you.

    1. Jessie avatar

      Thank you and yes I wanted to love it more but it was still a fun time 🙂

Leave a Reply


28 / 60 books. 47% done!

Join 62 other subscribers.

WELCOME

This is my cosy corner of the internet dedicated to all things books. I am an avid reader of mainly romance, fantasy, YA and mystery/thriller books. I hope to connect with other readers who share the same love for books that I do!

recent reviews
--------------------------------------

Discover more from Just Read Jessie

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading